TikTok blames human error on removal of same-sex kiss video.

What happens when a man kisses his boyfriend at the stroke of midnight on New Year’s Eve and posts it on the video-sharing social network, TikTok? The post is removed because it’s a violation of the platform’s community guidelines. That’s exactly what happened to me this New Year’s.
When I saw the notification on my profile, I was flooded with feelings of shame and alienation. After being out of the closet for 24 years, I knew I needed to take action for myself and for the entire LGBTQ community.
In a world where bullying is rampant, the relatively new platform that already reaches 60 million active monthly users in the US must support the equal and fair treatment of LGBTQ users and all diverse communities.
Most importantly, think about a teenager going through the same experience of having their video removed because they simply kissed their same-sex partner. Imagine how devastating it would feel when a popular social network tells them it’s not okay to be who they are. Many would be too afraid to speak up and would not know how to respond to this type of discrimination.
That’s why I chose to take action – for those who cannot.
I started by filing a support ticket and then tweeted the company. Finally, I emailed TikTok’s public relations department.
After explaining that I was writing a piece on the video being removed and demanding answers, my request was quickly forwarded to the moderation team. Within two hours, TikTok re-activated my video and let me know it had been incorrectly removed due to human error. I can hardly believe this was the reason the video was removed. If I hadn’t shared with TikTok PR that I was writing an article, I doubt the company would have responded so rapidly.
The initial removal of my video appears to be a continuation of TikTok’s reported bias against the LGBTQ community.
Indeed, late last year, TikTok admitted to suppressing videos from LGBTQ users in what the platform called a “flawed attempt” to prevent bullying.
TikTok provided an empty defense of its policies, saying “…in response to an increase in bullying on the app, we implemented a blunt and temporary policy.”
TikTok said the policy “was never designed to be a long-term solution,” adding, “While the intention was good, it became clear that the approach was wrong and we have since removed the policy in favor of more nuanced anti-bullying policies and in-app protections.”
The removal of my New Year’s Eve video makes the urgent case for a full internal evaluation of TikTok’s policies and moderation practices. A number of tough questions need to be answered.
If this decision was based on human error, who was the human? How does TikTok make hiring decisions for moderation positions? Is diversity represented on these teams? What about across the organization as a whole? And, most importantly, what will the company do to prevent a repeat of this experience?
The bottom line is we can’t allow a social media platform to commit discriminatory micro-aggressions against any community.
TikTok needs to continue to be called out for biased practices. It’s critical that the company understands its responsibility to create a safe and welcoming environment for all.
The clock is literally ticking for TikTok to make big changes. And, guess what, the alarm has gone off.
This article originally appeared on Campaign US.
Why Hallmark Channel’s apology is not enough.
What a weekend for the Hallmark Channel.
In case you missed it, the cable channel known for its cheerful, lovey-dovey holiday specials, where girl leaves the big city to move to a small town and meets the man of her dreams and ultimately decides to stay for love, found itself in a not-so-Hallmark-Channel setting this weekend.
The network pulled several ads from online wedding registry Zola featuring a same-sex couple kissing after facing pressure from a conservative group “One Million Moms,” according to multiple reports.
The public backlash was fast and fierce. With the hashtag #BoycottHallmark trending over the weekend, Hallmark was reminded that we live in 2019 and quickly changed course.
In a statement, Mike Perry, President and CEO, Hallmark Cards, apologized for what he called “the wrong decision,” and said the brand “will continue to look for ways to be more inclusive and celebrate our differences.”
While I applaud Hallmark’s quick reversal, the network will need to do a much deeper dive as the dust continues to settle. A complete internal audit needs to be done immediately and serious questions need to be answered, including:
- What happened after calls to pull the ads surfaced?
- Who was ultimately responsible for making the decision?
- What is the make-up of the team that makes these types of decisions? How will that change in the future, because it appears from this issue, it’s not a diverse one.
- How did a team of c-suite executives think pulling the ads was the appropriate response?
- What steps will Hallmark take to prevent it from happening in the future?
I want to know the answers to these questions, don’t you? For Hallmark, it’s time to be transparent and make their responses widely available.
If they are able to make this a learning experience for others in the industry who may be faced with the same decision, they may be able to gain respect from those they have hurt and, quite frankly, insulted.
What about programming?
I believe the decision to pull the spots is a symptom of a much larger issue at the network. It’s no secret the network lacks diversity and inclusion in its programming.
Moving forward, what changes will be made in the programming on-air? How will we start to see diversity in lead roles on the Hallmark Channel? If they’re really are going to embrace our differences, the stars featured in the programming need to reflect today’s heterogeneous society.
The bottom line
This past week goes beyond a serious PR fail for Hallmark. It’s a moment that will literally mark the brand in a negative way for years to come.
The only way to steer the ship back in the right direction is not by words, but by demonstrating their commitment with serious actions. Answer the tough questions. Be transparent. And, share what you’re doing next.
Hallmark Channel, will you do it?
This article originally appeared on Campaign US.
Launching an Ad Campaign. A Step-by-Step Method for PR.
Too often I see brands stumble out of the gate when it’s time to launch an ad campaign.
From cultural missteps to bad timing, brands sometimes get in their own way. To help maximize the most important moment of a campaign launch, here are seven simple steps to kick off a successful PR effort around an ad campaign.
Make Sure PR is Present at the Creation
In an environment ripe for potential cultural missteps, PR pros can provide valuable counsel. Having PR present at the onset of a campaign to help avoid embarrassing crises is the best scenario. Once the creative concept is developed, PR also can provide feedback on how the media (social and traditional) and the general public will react. Taking this step can avoid embarrassing press down the line.
Know Your Angle
Once communicators are confident the campaign will not be a PR disaster, it’s time to build a strong angle for pitching. PR pros should ask: Does this campaign tie into a current event? Does it assert a strong opinion? Does it resonate with a certain generation? Once you know the angle, write a pitch letter that will get an editor’s attention and generate buzz.
Develop the Pitch Strategy
Now it’s time to identify the right strategy, which will outline how the campaign will be pitched. For example, will it be pitched as an exclusive to one publication or will it be shared with multiple publications at the same time? The strategy should address the timing of the release and who will speak on behalf of the creative work.
Gather Key Assets
Some reporters and publications have a strong preference for the format of videos and images, whether it’s a YouTube link, video file or high-resolution jpeg. Make sure you have assets in the format your media targets prefer.
Be selective about assets you share. If you have a “hero” piece — one asset that you know you want to be included in press coverage — don’t send it through with six other options. Only share assets you would like to see in the eventual coverage of the campaign.
Get the Credits Right
It’s important to make sure credits are final and accurate. Submitting incorrect credits and requesting a correction after a story is posted is a fast way to sour a relationship with a reporter.
Secure Approvals
Have all key stakeholders signed off on the pitch? Don’t move forward with the pitch until this is done.
Pitch the Campaign
Now you are ready to pitch. Make sure key creative leaders are available to speak to the press. An easy and quick way to get media angry is to offer an executive in a pitch who’s unwilling to speak with content creators.
What’s Next?
Once coverage begins to land, share the resulting articles internally and across your social media channels, including LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter, to extend the reach of your earned media coverage.
This article was originally published on PR News.
Please share this piece.
Many of the articles pitched by these executives, who aren’t journalists or writers by trade, lack thought-provoking content..
I recently learned that Campaign — and other publications like it — are considering cutting back on articles contributed by industry leaders and executives.
Lindsay Stein, US editor of Campaign, explained why. Many of the articles pitched by these executives, who aren’t journalists or writers by trade, lack thought-provoking content. When they do get published, companies often fail to share the live content.
In short, many thought leadership articles aren’t generating enough page views for publications. And without page views, there’s less advertising opportunities.
Is there still a chance to get published on sites like Campaign? Yes, if you know what you’re doing.
Here’s how to turn your industry expertise into content that people will actually read and share.
- Find a newsy angle
To get a reader’s attention, tie your article to something that’s getting a lot of buzz. That means you have to either think ahead or act fast. If you want to write your thoughts on Shonda Rhimes’ speech at Cannes, your piece should be ready the week of the festival or the Monday after it wraps. - Pick a format
You can give your opinion in an op-ed, you can analyze new trends in your industry, or you can offer a bulleted list of examples and instructions in an advice-driven article (as I’ve done here). - Don’t sell or self-promote
There’s no faster way to alienate your audience. Think about the people at a cocktail party who only talk about themselves. Would you rather talk to them or the people who ask how you’re doing? The same rule applies for thought leadership content. Focus on how you can help the reader. - Check the publication’s requirements
Be mindful of the outlet’s tone, style and submission guidelines. If editors request articles that are 500 words or less and you submit 1,200 words, they’re going to pass. - Go wide
Publications like to reach broad audiences, so pick a topic that will resonate across your industry. For example, if you’re considering an op-ed on new internet privacy rules, think about how it will affect not just marketers, but also media buyers, influencers and consumers. - Take a stand
Journalists have to be fair and balanced in their writing, but as a prominent executive, audiences want to know what you really think. If you’re writing an op-ed about, for example, why most companies are doing Instagram marketing all wrong, don’t hold back. - Share, share, share
Help drive traffic to your content (and therefore, the publication) by sharing the piece on LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter, and encourage your company to do the same. If you can rack up lots of views, the editor is likely to want to publish your next article.
The bottom line
Some editors, like Stein, review 30 to 40 submissions a day for just a handful of slots. Following these suggestions will help ensure your piece is considered, engages the largest audience, and materializes the benefits of thought leadership.
This article originally appeared on Campaign US.
Ready to meet the press at an industry event? 3 things to keep in mind!
5 PR tips for Democrats to connect with the American public.
The 3 lessons learned from the Equinox PR crisis.
Mark Allen & Co: We get your executives published.
I was a HuffPost blogger. Now what?
That sound you’re hearing is a collective gasp from the thousands of execs who used to blog on HuffPost.
The Verizon-owned publication recently announced it was shutting down its free blogging platform. Some 100,000-plus contributors used it to provide HuffPost with free content.
It’s the end of an era, but the beginning of a new one too. As we’ve seen recently on YouTube, letting content creators run wild can backfire. At HuffPost, with so many contributors, there was no way to maintain any level of quality control.
Unfortunately for executives who were dependent on HuffPost to share their points of view, they are finding it tougher to get published elsewhere. In our experience, many publications appear to be getting stricter on submissions or are limiting the number of submissions they are willing to accept from outside contributors.
What’s Next?
As a result, we are advising our clients to look more closely at self-syndication – especially on the social networks. No. 1 on the list is LinkedIn.
LinkedIn’s SEO is excellent now. So, for example, if you blog about a “PR management crisis,” your post has a good chance of showing up in Google’s first or second page. To make the platform work though, you need to go beyond posting a piece and connect with your LinkedIn network.
After posting your article, there are many tools to extend the reach of your post, from sponsoring it to creating a text ad. Many executives are also creating LinkedIn slideshare presentations based on their articles to extend the life of their pieces.
Want to make your post go further than LinkedIn? Then create a customized email distribution list or post creative Tweets about your latest piece.
The Bottom Line
While many executives may have been disheartened to hear about HuffPost’s decision, the future is bright for those executives who pursue a self-syndication strategy – especially on LinkedIn.
How United Airlines can solve PR crisis.
Well, that escalated quickly. Despite other things in the news, including the crisis in Syria, United Airlines was the biggest trending topic on Monday.
The reason? As you’ve likely seen, security dragged a bloodied passenger Dr. David Dao off the plane. The Chicago-Louisville flight was overbooked and Dao refused to get off.
The simple reason this made the rounds in the news and social media is that there was video of the incident – a very vivid and disturbing one.
This was a major crisis for United, one the airline could have handled much better. Here are four ways:
- Show indignation that this occurred.
Though he was PR Week’s Communicator of the Year, United CEO Oscar Munoz displayed a tin ear by offering a conditional apology about “having to re-accommodate…customers.” What was missing from Munoz’s statement was anger. If he’s not upset that some United employees acted this way, then that means he condones it. That’s a losing position. Instead, Munoz should have said something like, “No matter the facts behind this incident, United did not live up to our high standards for customer service and we will take steps to make sure this never happens again.” - Apologize via video.
Sometimes a written statement is not enough. Words can’t counteract the power of video. When Domino’s faced its own crisis a few years ago, President Patrick Doyle apologized on YouTube. That not only advanced the story, it also gave news outlets a new piece of media. And, it replaced the old images with new ones. - Make amends with the passenger.
Though Munoz issued an apology on Tuesday – two days after the incident occurred – he needs to go further. A goodwill gesture like contributing to Dao’s favorite charity would help. - Issue a plan to make sure this won’t happen again.
Most people would choose another airline over United while this incident is fresh in their mind. United can address this concern by being proactive and outlining a plan on how overbooking will be handled in the future. By issuing a public promise to customers, United can begin to quickly move past this crisis.
Bottom Line
By making a bad situation worse, United has undone millions in advertising spending. However, the opportunity still exists for United to make a right out of this major wrong.